« How was your weekend? | Main | Heralds of the Second Secular Coming: AKA as Fools at the Midnight Hour »

October 28, 2007

Hate Crimes vs. Thought Crimes

When I heard about H.R. 1955, I thought it was about hate crimes. I was wrong. It's about thought crimes. The latest anti-terrorism bill - presented by a Democrat, is H.R. 1955: Violent Radicalization and Homegrown Terrorism Prevention Act of 2007. I have always been against hate crimes laws and from what I'm reading so far, I think I am against H.R. 1955, which some are calling a "thought crimes" bill. But is it really about thought crimes?

Presently this bill does not create any new laws. What it does do is create a commission to do a study:

... Nowhere in there does it establish any criminal penalties or say that anything that falls within the definitions violate any criminal code of the US. What it does do is establish a commission to study things that the "commission" decides falls within those definitions and report back to congress those findings every 6 months with a final report due in 18 months. This bill does not "in essence" create thought crimes, but it does set up a commission to study them. It is not "the legislation" to implement them ... (more at Free Market News Network)

The bill is supposed to be about "preventing violent radicalization, homegrown terrorism, and ideologically based violence in the United States [and] is critical to combating domestic terrorism."

(b) Purpose- The purposes of the Commission are the following:

(1) Examine and report upon the facts and causes of violent radicalization, homegrown terrorism, and ideologically based violence in the United States, including United States connections to non-United States persons and networks, violent radicalization, homegrown terrorism, and ideologically based violence in prison, individual or lone wolf’ violent radicalization, homegrown terrorism, and ideologically based violence, and other faces of the phenomena of violent radicalization, homegrown terrorism, and ideologically based violence that the Commission considers important.

(2) Build upon and bring together the work of other entities and avoid unnecessary duplication, by reviewing the findings, conclusions, and recommendations of–

(A) the Center of Excellence established or designated under section 899D, and other academic work, as appropriate;

(B) Federal, State, local, or tribal studies of, reviews of, and experiences with violent radicalization, homegrown terrorism, and ideologically based violence; and

(C) foreign government studies of, reviews of, and experiences with violent radicalization, homegrown terrorism, and ideologically based violence.

Section 899D of the bill establishes a Center of Excellence for the Study of Violent Radicalization and Homegrown Terrorism in the United States. Essentially, this will be a Department of Homeland Security affiliated institution that will study and determine how to defeat thought criminals. (more)

Some say this violates our civil rights and goes against the Constitution.

This bill is one of the most blatant attacks against the Constitution yet and actually defines thought crimes as homegrown terrorism. If passed into law, it will also establish a commission and a Center of Excellence to study and defeat so called thought criminals. Unlike previous anti-terror legislation, this bill specifically targets the civilian population of the United States and uses vague language to define homegrown terrorism. Amazingly, 404 of our elected representatives from both the Democrat and Republican parties voted in favor of this bill. There is little doubt that this bill is specifically targeting the growing patriot community that is demanding the restoration of the Constitution. (more at roguegovernment)

With Hate crimes laws a criminal, whether he is guilty of murder, rape, whatever, is given a more severe punishment because the hate thoughts he/she had leading up to the crime. I think this is wrong. With HATE crimes laws:

While motive or state of mind are routinely considered in criminal cases (as mitigating or aggravating factors,) ideology is not routinely invoked in determining the seriousness of an alleged crime. Hate crime legislation, however, is expressly designed to punish particular thoughts or ideas.

Its advocates argue that hate crimes demand differential treatment because they are crimes against communities, not just individuals. Hate crimes "are more serious than a normal assault because they target not just an individual, but an entire group of people," [snip]

When someone convicted of assaulting one woman is subject to an enhanced prison sentence or a more vigorous prosecution because his assault was motivated by a hateful belief in the inherent inferiority of all women, then he is being punished for his thoughts as well as his conduct. (Wall Street Journal)

It seems that H.R. 1955 may have some very good intentions. With home grown terrorists, we want to catch them before they actually carry out a terror attack on American soil. But I don't believe anyone would be arrested for what someone in government thinks the individual has in his/her mind, without tangible material evidence to back up the charges.

What do you think about this bill?
_______________________________________________________________________________
Asking the question and Trackposted to Stop the ACLU, Lost Paradise, Perri Nelson's Website, , A Blog For All, AZAMATTEROFACT, guerrilla radio, 123beta, Stix Blog, The Populist, Big Dog's Weblog, The Amboy Times, Cao's Blog, Conservative Cat, Jo's Cafe, Adeline and Hazel, Conservative Thoughts, Nuke's, third world county, The Crazy Rants of Samantha Burns, The Uncooperative Radio Show!, The World According to Carl, Pirate's Cove, Blue Star Chronicles, The Pink Flamingo, Republican National Convention Blog, CORSARI D'ITALIA, Right Voices, and Church and State, thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c49a69e200e54f14592b8834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Hate Crimes vs. Thought Crimes:

» A new villian for the Nutroots from Stix Blog
So we have hear that Global Warning is to blame for the fires in California, and partly to blame for Bush because of all the equipment and National Guard in Iraq and Afghanistan. But the real culpret is Blackwater. See [Read More]

» Democracies at4GWar from Wolf Pangloss
Counterinsurgency and Fourth Generation Warfare (4GW) are two ways of saying the same thing. War compels an enemy to submit to your will. 4GW is a form of warfare. It is still a technique for compulsion. However, it does not focus directly on the enemy... [Read More]

» BREAKING: What a Day! The Red Sox Win & Tancredo Calls It Quits! from The Pink Flamingo
TANCREDO HANGS IT UP!
[Read More]

» Who Wouldve Thunk The NFL Would Outsource Games from Right Voices
Today, the New York Giants and the Miami Dolphins played to a sold out crowd at Wembley Stadium in London. “I don’t think you can be meaningful forever if you’re not part of the global community, particularly in this day and age,” Waller sai... [Read More]

» “Christian” Conservative “Values”: Amnesia or Something Else? from The Pink Flamingo
A “CHRISTIAN” HIT ON GIULIANI?
[Read More]

» Open Trackback Weekend from 123beta
*Reciprocal Ping* - Time for another trackback party. I'm getting geared up to spook some little trick-or-treaters... [Read More]

» Syria Forging U.S. Government Documents from The Yankee Sailor
In their continuing effort to manipulate the politics of Lebanon, it looks like Syrian intelligence has stooped to creating counterfeit U.S. documents to incite anti-American sentiment prior to Novembers elections. ... [Read More]

» An Interesting Reflection from Rhymes With Right
The great Buddhas of Bamiyan were destroyed by the Taliban in 201. It was a great loss for the cultural heritage of all humanity. Roger Cohen reflects on that loss today, following a recent visit to the site. People still... [Read More]

» Pro-Border-Jumper Groups Seek To Stop Law Against Illegals from Rhymes With Right
Because after all, we wouldn’t want to make those breaking the law feel uncomfortable, stigmatized or unwelcome. One of the toughest state laws targeting illegal immigrants takes effect Thursday in Oklahoma, prompting efforts by immigrants trying to bl... [Read More]

» Project Valour-IT -- Team Navy from Rhymes With Right
Project Valour-IT, in memory of SFC William V. Ziegenfuss, helps provide voice-controlled and adaptive laptop computers to wounded Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen and Marines recovering from hand wounds and other severe injuries at major military medical cen... [Read More]

» Saudi King Preaches to UK on Terrorism from The Amboy Times
Taqiyya, plain and simple.Saudi Arabia's King Abdullah has accused Britain of not doing enough to fight international terrorism, which he says could take 20 or 30 years to beat. He was speaking in a BBC interview ahead of a state [Read More]

» Supporting Project Valour - IT! from Diary of the Mad Pigeon
Project Valour-IT, in memory of SFC William V. Ziegenfuss, helps provide voice-controlled and adaptive laptop computers to wounded Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen and Marines recovering from hand wounds and other severe injuries at major military medical cen... [Read More]

» Tropicl Storm Noel Gains Strength...causes destruc from Gulf Coast Hurricane Tracker
Tropical Storm Noel brought heavy rain and flooding to the Dominican Republic on Monday and officials said at least 20 people had died. [Read More]

» A Shocking Lack of Historical Knowledge Is Condemning the Left from The Pink Flamingo
GREENLAND GLOBAL WARMING<... [Read More]

» An Open Letter To Young Would Be Martyrs... from 123beta
As the jihad continues I've often pondered why young islamic children would succumb to their elders' request to become martyrs... [Read More]

» Mosques have Terrorists?..Who Knew! from Woman Honor Thyself
Uh. Huh. And our First Lady is busy posing in an ab–aya, the symbol of Izzlam’s oppression of women. Nice shmata Laura. ... [Read More]

» Vets for Freedom reaching out to spread good news from Rosemary's Thoughts
URL: http://rosemarysthoughts.blogspot.com/2007/10/vets-for-freedom-reaching-out-to-spread.html This is a worthy cause and one we've been searching to join. Well, here's your opportunity. Just think about it. All you have to do is write about the t... [Read More]

» Vets for Freedom reaching out to spread good news from Rosemary's Thoughts
URL: http://rosemarysthoughts.blogspot.com/2007/10/vets-for-freedom-reaching-out-to-spread.html This is a worthy cause and one we've been searching to join. Well, here's your opportunity. Just think about it. All you have to do is write about the t... [Read More]

» Dont Let Politics Ruin Your Life from Adam's Blog
Podcast Show Notes Here are our topics: 1) Dont let politics ruin your life like these people. (Hat Tip: Right Wing News.) 2) The Atheist brainwashing campaign. (Hat Tip: Evangelical Outpost.) 3) Governor Matt Blunt (R-MO) sued for taking a hard... [Read More]

» Response to Wildfires by Military not Hampered by Deployments from Big Dogs Weblog
It did not take long for people to blame George Bush for the wildfires in California because of his [past] opposition to global warming and because of a general hatred of the man. People compare the response to the wildfires with the response to Katri... [Read More]

» Who's Your Candidate? from Shadowscope
this is my open-trackback post for Tuesday October 20th, the day before Halloween. My question is this. If you are voting in the Republican Primaries, who is going to be your candidate. This is entirely anonymous but I would also be interested in heari... [Read More]

Comments

It's a bad piece of legislation, even if it is only for the purposes of studying Violent Radicalization and Homegrown Terrorism.

One way to tell a bad law is to ask - do we already have laws that address violent acts and terrorism. The answer is yes, we arrest would-be terrorists and violent perpetrators already. Consider the arrest of 4 men this past year for attempting to blow up JFK's airports fuel depot and the FBI arrest of 7 black Muslim men in Miami who were reportedly discussing a terrorist plot. In both cases, arrests were made, the men were indicted, and they had NOT YET committed a violent terrorist act. So our current laws are working.

The law is bad also for the vagueness of the language. In essence, the law may eventually enable the government to cast a wider net to arrest and prosecute people for simply being angry with government policies.

Lastly, this law is basically a copy of an existing "extremism" law in Russia that has been widely criticized by the West, for many of the same reasons cited above.

You can read more about that law here: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/09/03/AR2007090300470.html

When Putin passes such a law, we call him a dictator. What are we if we follow in those footsteps?

Thanks everybody for the comments. I'm still not sure what I think about this "committee". If it helps catch terrorists then I'm probably for it. But we need to be very careful when trying to legislate what someone might be thinking.

Good blog Deb.

I also did a blog on this subject last week.

I've ranted against the concept of hate crimes as actually being nothing but thought crimes enough that I don't need to do it again. What I find scarey about this is the idea of a "Center of Excellence for the Study of Violent Radicalization and Homegrown Terrorism in the United States". Center of Excellence? What?

Where in Hell did they come up with a name like that and more importantly, WHY? That's so similar to Orwells "Ministry of Truth", whose purpose was to spread propaganda lies, that it gives me chills.

"Center of Excellence". Hi. Center of Exellence here. We are wonderful here. We are excellent and beyond question here.

The name means absolutely NOTHING. It's SPIN! Sweet, gooey pap for the masses. Therefor it's not valid, not to be trusted and most likely one more attack on our Constitution and our freedom.

Hawai'i was great but it great to be back, too.

Rasta

Sorry I posted the reply below in the wrong window.

When I was a kid, I never missed Richard Boone starring as Paladin. Have gun, will travel.

Boy, that Richard Boone was one ugly dude!

i have the cure - give them one little shot of sodium pentothol before ANY questioning. BAM!

honestly - i'm not sure what to think of this bill - i do know, however, that MOST crimes have malice aforethought - very few are accidental...something to think about.

What do I think of it?
I think that the nerve impulses in my skull are my own damn business, thank you very much.

What happens when those impulses reach my voice box or hand, that's everyone else's business.

Maybe.

the problem is Deb that the Mussslims are using all these laws against us..........all of them!:)

And just what type of "thought" is this combatting? While I disagree with the Bill as I don't see how it can be implemented, could it be that it is legislating agsinst the very group you all love to hate? That ideologically based "religion of peace" y'all are always railing on against...the IMAMS standing there and preaching jihad.

This is nothing more than yet another masked attempt from the Left to stifle conservative speech, by trying to brand it -- through a "commission" -- a "thought crime". Progressive effort at nothing short of "thought control".

Kill the bill.

"Hate Crimes" That is the dumbest piece of legislation that there is, it's not a hate crime when a Church says that the act of Homosexuality is against the scriptures, it is more of a fact that the teaching says that we don't hate the individual but the act of the homosexual is what is wrong according to the scriptures.

When a person murders some one that is a hate crime if one wants a definition of Murder they don't murder you because they love you.

That is the whole problem with this Political Correctness scenario is that no one can tell anymore what is morally wrong and morally right.

They need to get rid of that ridiculous ruling.

It even states that in the Bible that, that is one of the signs of the coming END OF TIMES when "Wrong will look like right" and "Right will look like Wrong" when good will look like Evil and Evil like Good.

Be there forewarned that the far leftists will bring about THE END OF TIMES sooner than any other group.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Welcome

Translate by Google

Search Right Truth with Google Search


  • Google

    WWW
    righttruth.typepad.com

Author

  • Debbie Hamilton
Subscribe

Feeds

July 2009

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31  

The Watcher's Council



Google Page Rank

BlogRankers


  • BlogRankers.com

Wikio Blogs

  • Wikio - Top of the Blogs - Politics

Blogged

Right Truth Mosaic


Important Information

Grab Me For Your Site

Book Club Now Reading

Jerusalem Post


  • Vote for Right Truth articles

AutoPinger

  • Blog: Right Truth - Get your quick ping button at autopinger.com!

World Blog Archive

  • Blog RSS/Atom Feed Aggregator and Syndicate

Blogroll Me

I support Israel

Thank You Troops

Knife and Multi-Tool Website

Pledge to Survive

Patient Evil

Disclaimer


  • This blog is an exercise in the author's First Amendment Rights as pertaining to Free Speech with all the protections as afforded & granted by the Constitution of the United States of America. The blog owner is not responsible for content of sites linking to this blog or sites that this blog links to. Opinions quoted on this blog or left as comments on this blog, do not necessarily represent the opinions of the blog owner. Opinions included in articles written by anyone other than the blog owner, do not necessarily represent the opinions of the blog owner. If you are offended by anything written, quoted, excerpted, referenced, linked to ... on this blog: Then go somewhere else.


  • Bloggers' Rights at EFF

blogroll

Site Meter

Crescent of Betrayal Blogroll

Tennessee ConserVOLiance

Southern Blog Federation Blogroll

Webloggin

Freedom's Zone Blogroll

Jihadi Du Jour

  • Who wants to kill us and why!
Blog powered by TypePad
Member since 10/2005

Feeds