Obama Trying To Take Credit For It To Bolster Election Chances…
Via Atlantic Wire:
Israel’s officials have a message for anyone praising the CIA for its sophisticated cyber attack on Iran: It was our baby. The Stuxnet computer worm, described by David Sanger in The New York Times last week as an invention by the Bush administration, was actually developed by Mossad, according to Israeli officials speaking with Haaretz journalist Yossi Melman on condition of anonymity:
The Israeli officials actually told me a different version. They said that it was Israeli intelligence that began, a few years earlier, a cyberspace campaign to damage and slow down Iran’s nuclear intentions. And only later they managed to convince the USA to consider a joint operation — which, at the time, was unheard of.
The irony of course is that both U.S. and Israeli officials spent years denying knowledge of who carried out the attacks, which reportedly destroyed thousands of Iran’s centrifuges, ever since it became public in 2010. Now that it’s out, it’s time to claim credit! Of course, if you read Sanger’s account, he certainly doesn’t diminish the expertise of Israel’s spies:
Israel’s Unit 8200, a part of its military, had technical expertise that rivaled the N.S.A.’s, and the Israelis had deep intelligence about operations at Natanz that would be vital to making the cyberattack a success.
Regardless, these Israeli officials say Sanger’s account was too generous to the CIA. Amusingly, one of the officials tries to play it cool, in his remark to Melman:
My Israeli sources understand the sensitivity and the timing of the issue and are not going to be dragged into a battle over taking credit. “We know that it is the presidential election season,” one Israeli added, ”and don’t want to spoil the party for President Obama and his officials, who shared in a twisted and manipulated way some of the behind-the-scenes secrets of the success of cyberwar.”
Keep reading…, (hat tip Weasel Zippers)
I grant Mossad "slightly" more credibility than the CIA, but both organizations are FAR from the super-effective groups portrayed by Hollywood and the media. Mossad failures would astound people if they actually knew...
If I had to acertain a source for Stuxnet, my analysis would be something like:
1. National Security Agency.
2. Mossad/CIA.
3. U.S. military intelligence cyber warfare units (exclusive of NSA).
4. Chinese cyber warfare specialists.
Accordingly, it is possible that the CIA had some influence, whether by intention or not.
Since Iran is BFF with China, I placed them #4 for this reason. Truthfully, Chinese capabilities are probably just behind (barely) NSA.
Posted by: R.J. Godlewski | June 10, 2012 at 08:01 PM
From what i've read about this, it infects not only the host, but can jump from one system to another in a matter of seconds, and there is really no way to stop it , unless you shut down all systems really fast. I bet it's causing Ahmadinejihad a lot of sleepless nights. I'm of the opinion it was a joint deal with NSA and israeli specialists.
Posted by: PALADIN | June 10, 2012 at 11:20 PM